Strata roof repairs generate more disputes than almost any other maintenance item because the boundaries between common property, individual lot property, and insurance cover aren't always intuitive. This is a plain-English guide (not legal advice, and every scheme's by-laws vary), but it covers the common cases we see in NSW.
The general rule in NSW
Under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), the roof is almost always common property, meaning the owners' corporation is responsible for maintaining and repairing it. This applies whether the roof is a single roof over the whole building or an individual roof over a townhouse-style lot in a strata scheme.
What sits underneath the roof (ceiling linings, insulation, wall linings, floor coverings) is generally lot property (individual owner responsibility) even when it's damaged by a common-property roof failure.
So who pays for the roof itself?
The owners' corporation, through the strata levies. Roof repairs, restorations and replacements are common-property expenses. The committee approves the scope through the process defined in the scheme's by-laws, usually a general meeting for expenditure above a threshold set in the by-laws.
What about damage inside the unit from a roof leak?
Here's where it gets genuinely complicated. The general rule:
- The owners' corporation is responsible for stopping the leak (roof repair).
- The individual lot owner is responsible for repairing damaged ceiling linings, paint, floor coverings inside their lot.
- The strata insurance may cover both if the damage arose from a sudden insurable event (storm) rather than gradual deterioration.
- The lot owner's contents insurance may cover contents damage regardless.
In practice, most well-run schemes with reasonable strata insurance will run the whole event through the strata insurance claim and let the insurer sort out who pays for what. Poorly-run schemes end up with the lot owner out of pocket for internal damage while the committee argues about the roof.
The best defence: preventative maintenance and asset planning
The disputes almost always happen when a leak is a surprise: nobody planned for it, nobody budgeted for it, and now there's an angry owner with a stained ceiling. A proper roof asset management plan changes the conversation. When the roof is inspected annually, defects are tracked, and the ten-year capital works schedule has 'ridge cap re-bedding: year 4' and 'full re-roof: year 12' in it, the leak stops being a surprise.
It's why the strata schemes we work with long-term have far fewer roof-related disputes than the ones we only meet after something has already failed. See our roof asset management service for how this works in practice.
This article is general information only. Every strata scheme's by-laws vary, and specific disputes should be referred to your strata manager or a strata lawyer for advice on your circumstances.





